Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Gender Bender

For some reason, this week's prompt brings to mind "pregnant man" Thomas Beatie, who I just found out is pregnant again. While I like to think of myself as pretty open-minded when it comes to sexual identity, I've got to admit I have a pretty hard time wrapping my head around this one. I mean, if Thomas truly desires to change his (her?) sex to that of a man, why is he so attracted to pregnancy and giving birth? It would seem to make more sense if he had been born a transgendered male and wanted to give birth as a woman. As far as gender roles go, the role of giving birth seems to me to be decidedly female, and I'm not sure there's anything we can do to change that (as much as I'd love to pull a seahorse and force my husband to carry any babies I might want).

In some ways, Thomas is an example of the contemporary truth that women today have to resort to pretty extreme behavior to be considered "masculine" (and vice versa), because gender roles today are so much broader than they were in the time of Lucy Brewer and Almira Paul. In some ways, gender reassignment surgery is the ultimate form of cross-dressing. However, although there are still men who wish to be women and women who wish to be men (and more power to both groups), more and more men and women are becoming comfortable with the idea of "violating" traditional gender roles. In some ways, Thomas is the physical manifestation of the modern pick-and-choose philosophy regarding gender and behavior. Thomas isn't trying to be completely male, but he doesn't want to be considered female either.

Childrearing seems to be the last frontier in terms of gender roles. There aren't nearly as many men rushing home to take care of the kids as there were women running for the workplace during the feminist movement. This would seem to lend credence to the idea that the "woman's role" was never that desirable in the first place. Which came first? Does our society disdain the task of staying home to take care of the kids because it's associated with women, or is it a job women got stuck with because men get first dibs in a patriarchal society? There's one school of thought that says we're more accepting of women being strong, logical, and assertive than we are men being weak, emotional, and passive because we prefer the first set of characteristics in people regardless of their sex. Do we like these characteristics because they're associated with masculinity or do we associate them with masculinity because it's another characteristic that our society prizes? Since I have to profess a strong preference for strength, logic, and standing up for one's self, I prefer the second explanation.

In any case, I find it ironic that the first "man" to give birth wasn't a man who wanted to be a woman, but a woman who wanted to be a man. Typical.

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

The Parent Trap

In many ways, Mr. Temple and Lucy seem to be the perfect parents, even if they're a little over-indulgent by the standards of the time. (Lucy wants to throw a birthday party for her daughter - for shame, for shame.) Their marriage seems to function as an example of what marrying for love should be. "Plenty, and her handmaid, Prudence, presided at their board, Hospitality stood at their gate, Peace smiled on each face, Content reigned in each heart, and Love and Health strewed roses on their pillows." Even after Charlotte's fall, Lucy is able to derive comfort from the fact that she always set a perfect example for her daughter.

Instead, Charlotte's fall seems to result from the corrupting influences of the outside world. Montraville, Belcour, La Rue, and luck all seem to have it in for poor Charlotte, who has little say in her fate after she is seduced by Montraville's letter. There also seems to be some insinuation that society has doomed women by making them too weak and dependent. The book constantly refers to Charlotte's "resolutions," and goes out of its way to praise certain actions that flew in the face of 18th-century societal norms. In defends Lucy's emotional strength and Mr. Temple's sentimentality. We are meant to love Emily for reaching out to Charlotte, even though the conventional moral standards of the time would have condemned her. Hanging out with a harlot would irreparably stain a good woman's spotless reputation. Likewise, the novel portrays Charlotte's landlady as insensitive, while Mather would have congratulated her on doing the right thing. Rowson seems to think that the moral standards set to prevent female depravity are at least partly to blame for its prevalence.

Ultimately, the parents of today, much like Charlotte's, are powerless to prevent their daughters from going out and getting into trouble. On the other hand, I think most modern parents would agree that the point of parenting is to equip one's children with the confidence and critical thinking skills to make the right decision on their own. Not everyone goes about it the same way--some parents think the best way to do this is by being as strict as possible so that their children have no questions about what's right and what's wrong. Others operate under the philosophy that kids should be given as much autonomy as possible from an early age so they learn from experience and adjust to having a lot of responsibility.

As usual, the best approach is probably somewhere in between the two extremes.