Thursday, October 30, 2008

A TV Wasteland

I imagine that the person responsible for "Novel Reading: a Cause of Female Depravity" would name the medium of television as a contemporary source of female depravity. There's certainly no shortage of depictions of women behaving badly for them to blame.

The first show that comes to mind as the modern equivalent of early American romance novels is the guilty pleasure "Desperate Housewives." Sex out of wedlock, extramarital affairs, and disobedient daughters, oh my! Gabrielle would be castigated up one side and down the other for her penchant for sleeping with minors, her unbridled vanity, and her scanty attire. Susan would be similarly censured for being a divorcee. Lynette would be in trouble for wearing the pants in the family and God only knows what she'd say about Edie. The author would likely have the most sympathy for Bree, with her struggle to maintain traditional values in the face of a morally "progressive" community.

"Grey's Anatomy" would be another target for his or her darts of displeasure. Meredith's promiscuity, Izzie's child out of wedlock, and Christina's planned abortion all fly in the face of conservative values. And I haven't actually seen "Gossip Girl," but I've heard enough to know that its depiction of teenaged privilege and the so-called "hook-up culture" would upset most older Americans. Crime dramas, soap operas, to say nothing of cable shows--there's enough sleeping around on television to make the author's head spin!

However, I think a modern day cultural critic, like the angry letter-writers of yore, would be overestimating the impact entertainment media have in our lives. TV networks wouldn't show these programs if the ratings weren't thriving. Everyone loves a good scandal. Besides, how would cultural critics know what was on these shows if they weren't watching?

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

The More Things Change...

I can't speak for my classmates, but personally, I've felt a mounting frustration with the heroines--or should I say victims?--of the narratives that our class has read lately. I've always been the kind of girl to take the bull by the horns. Whether it's my natural personality, my modern upbringing, or some shortcoming in the text, I find I just can't relate to many of these women. I mean, ripping out chunks of your own flesh? How much more pathetic can you get?

Of course, it could well be the reason I can't relate to the women in the texts is that they're so thoroughly fictitious. It could be the massive age gap (two or three centuries) between me and the women depicted in the text, but it's hard to believe that anyone could really be so helpless. However, I may be losing sight of the fact that, while 18th century fiction often masqueraded as fact, most of the women we've been reading about, at least recently, are merely figments of the male imagination. They have even less connection with reality than the women in the conversion narratives we read earlier in class.

At the same time, I almost wonder whether they're might not be some truth to Mrs. Short Metre's observation that "they are both at fault," at least superficially. Given the time in which "The Passenger" was published, it's likely readers assumed Mrs. Short Metre meant that the woman had done something to deserve the beating. But I still have a hard time understanding why battered women don't leave their abusive spouses today. At least the woman in the tavern had more of an excuse, because I think public opinion and laws today are more supportive of women in those situations (or at least, I hope so). I know it's more complicated than that, but once again, I find myself unable to see myself in these women's shoes. It seems like we've gone from one extreme to the other: from seeing women as helpless victims who still somehow deserve any beatings their husbands can dish out to seeing them as empowered, equal citizens without holding them responsible for their (in)action.

I guess what frustrates me the most about the whole "women's roles" situation is the fact that things have clearly changed so little. I'm disappointed with society, which claims to have embraced and empowered women but still produces many young ladies who feel incomplete or inadequate without a boyfriend or husband. (Just look at all the magazine articles dedicated to helping women today find and keep a man and the sorts of things their authors suggest women resort to in order to do it. Besides, why else would a woman stay with someone who is emotionally or physically abusive?) However, I'm also a bit disappointed with women. When things have gone so long without changing, you begin to wonder. I mean, the fact we haven't been able to turn things around by now seems to suggest a lack of initiative--or even worse, a lack of ability.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Down with Love

I think the texts we discussed in class the other day made it clear that the idea of marriage based on love was one old-school Americans loved to hate. It's obvious why parents would see the demise of arranged marriage as a threat to their authority--how could any family eke out a good business or political deal without the ability to use its daughters as bargaining chips? Clearly, the best way to maintain control over your daughter was to convince her that you were the only person with her best interests at heart. While seduction tales were obviously meant to be dramatic and entertaining, the authors' main goal seems to be to convince young women that members of the opposite sex cannot be trusted.

In many ways, the seduction narratives echo the confession narratives we read earlier in the semester. In "Story of Amelia," Amelia mourns the "youthful folly" that led her astray. Like the confessing criminals of old, Amelia states that her main goal in writing her letter is to warn other girls not to make the same mistakes she did--"let them learn of me."

If seduction narratives are the new confession narratives, it stands to reason that love is the new sin. Young women are reputed to be especially at risk for romance, just as they were once seen as being more susceptible to sin. This time it is love, not sin, that is the "enemy within [Amelia's] own bosom. It is love, not sin, that makes her heart "weak and susceptible."

The other stories also seem to be geared towards warning young ladies of the dangers of love. These authors are definitely out to instruct girls in what they ought and ought not to do. They have only their best interests at heart. And if they make some money from selling these scandalous stories, that's just an added bonus.

Thursday, October 9, 2008

Leaf Blowers (?) - Modern Rakes

I wanted to find one or two modern "rakes" and do some sort of deep analysis of their character and psychology, but it's proven rather difficult. It's hard to do anything more than a superficial analysis of "rakes;" frankly, there doesn't seem to be much bellow the surface to scratch.

The most obvious example of the rake in contemporary American literature is Ryan Phillippe's character Sebastian in Cruel Intentions, which, of course, is based on an 18th century French novel itself. Sebastian is definitely a "player," as we would call him nowadays, and sets about corrupting virgins Annette and Cecile in the hopes that his stepsister will sleep with him. I can't decide if that makes it a more or less valid example of how modern American culture has updated the rake of 18th and 19th centuries. In any case, I thought it was interesting that Sebastian's stepsister is ultimately seen as being the one most at fault for all of the crimes of virtue being committed in the movie. Apparently, not a lot has changed.

Interestingly enough, Phillippe ended up being something of a rake in real life, leaving the amazing Reese Whitherspoon (who played Annette--the two met on the movie set) and their two children for one of his other costars, a fascinating example of life imitating art.

A recent remake of an old British film, Alfie, is all about the rake character. Alfie is a promiscuous limo driver who has strings of one night stands and dumps women the second they seem interested in an actual relationship. He cheats on his single mother girlfriend on a regular basis and impregnates his best friend's fiancee.

In yet another instance of art , Jude Law also turns out to be a real-life rake, cheating on his own fiancee Sienna Miller with his children's nanny. Classy.

Finally, we have an actor whose caddish behavior predated his rakish roles in the movies (or at least some of them)--Hugh Grant. In 1995, Grant was caught cheating on gorgeous longtime girlfriend Elizabeth Hurley with--wait for it--a common prostitute. Later, he played scumbags in romantic comedies Bridget Jones's Diary and About a Boy.

Is anyone else noticing a trend? Apparently, the men who pretend to be scoundrels really are. It reminds me of something Oscar Wilde said in Lady Windemere's Fan. I can't remember exactly how it was worded, but it had something to do with the fact that women never took men who professed to be scoundrels seriously.

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

The Not-So Happy Medium

In a weird way, it was rather refreshing to see society's "rules" for young women set out in black and white. Seeing societal norms in print only reinforces how self-contradictory and unattainable they really are.

For starters, women in early America were supposed to be confident in the world of romance while remaining sexually in the dark. How can a woman project confidence when dealing with subjects she knows nothing about? Is it any wonder that women ended up getting pregnant out of wedlock? This is taking abstinence-only education to a whole new level. Alphonzo's assertion that women must remain intellectually and emotionally childlike in order to attract a mate is downright creepy.

The idea that women should respond politely to ladies' men but refrain from engaging in any coquetry of their own is equally preposterous. We all knew there was a "double standard," but seeing it written out like that definitely makes one question just how Alphonzo and his brethren reached the conclusion that they were women's intellectual superiors.

Alphonzo's criticism of "prudes" is perhaps the most ridiculous of all. A woman who behaves too modestly is even more likely to be considered sexually suspect than a total floozy, he says. One can't help but wonder if this is just his way of consoling himself when women reject his advances.

Finally, only a few moments after we are told that most women don't like to read, the address's author criticizes women for their terrible taste in literature. Women are told that by choosing books that will increase their feminine charm, they can get away with reading less. Why worry about the quality of reading material that women are exposed to if they don't read any of it anyway? Doesn't that inadvertently suggest that no woman will read his letter unless it's a load of crap to begin with?


Women shouldn't try to live out a particular role but be true to themselves, Alphonzo says. But doesn't that mean they should also reject the role he's just set out for them? Women are supposed to be deferential: they have no control over their lives, yet society still holds them responsible for every little imaginary fault they can come up with.

I'd like to say that things have changed today, but there do seem to be definite parallels between the garbage espoused by magazines from the 18th century and that advocated by the magazines of today. Women are still encouraged to find that impossible middle ground, and it's a razor-sharp line that no man or woman can actually walk.