Wednesday, September 24, 2008

So Easy, a Cave-Woman Could Do It

"The Panther Narrative" definitely reflects a change in print culture attitudes towards women. How much of a change is still a question open for debate.

We got the first clue that early American writers were moving away from sermon-y conversion narratives and more towards sensational adventure stories in the "confession" of Rachel Wall, whose public "confessions" consisted of barely-disguised boasts of her "nocturnal excursions."

In some ways, the Panther cave-woman's situation seems markedly improved over that of her predecessors'. However, a closer examination of the text reveals that her progress seems to be of a "two steps forward, one step back" nature. It's true, there's little direct criticism of the woman and her lover's decision to elope, but it's a mere four days after they leave society and its antiquated ideas about love and marriage behind that he comes to a band end and she finds herself in a sticky situation. Even the original version of the Panther narrative, where she planned and executes a clever escape from the Indians, wouldn't have been giving her too much credit. (Have you ever checked out early Americans' attitudes towards the Natives?) Yes, she kills her would-be rapist, but her assertion that she would prefer death to having her honor violated just goes to show that "uncleanness" was still a big deal. Moreover, the fact that she inherited this cave and some of its contents from the man she killed (in his sleep, not in a proper fight) detracts from the ingenuity that would have been required for her to survive in the wilderness for nine years.

Besides, in the beginning of this tall tale the narrator mentions the various foodstuffs found growing in the Western forests "afforded us very comfortable living." The real purpose of the Panther narrative? It's basically an advertising gimmick. "Living off the land out west: So easy, a cave-woman could do it."

Don't get me wrong--it was nice to read a story where the woman doesn't die at the end. But I find it highly suspicious that our first encounter with a woman who goes unpunished for her disobedience is in an obviously fictitious tale. That's not to say that fiction can't be a good indicator of cultural realities, but I suspect early American women would have preferred a bit more progress in the real world.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Mixed Messages

There seems to be a lot of ambivalence towards the modern world's so-called sluts. It's hard to pinpoint society's feelings about the free-lovin' girls of today since attitudes differ so radically from one group to the next--even individuals often have mixed feelings about these issues. The general consensus seems to be that these situations should be taken on a case-by-case basis, which may be something of a double standard in and of itself.

It's hard to discuss modern attitudes towards male and female promiscuity and infanticide without bringing up abortion, which is in some ways unfortunate. Doing so only highlights the fact that some groups feel abortion and infanticide are basically the same thing, a stance I personally disagree with, and somewhat strongly. (I mean, I can't imagine anyone from the Puritan OR the modern era speaking out in support of infanticide.) Nevertheless, the fact remains that women who become pregnant now have an option Puritan women did not. I would guess that in Puritan times, the more conservative churches were often the ones that treated unwed mothers the most harshly. However, today's conservative fellowships' staunch anti-abortion stance puts them in a bit of a pickle. Many of them still consider sex out of wedlock to be a serious sin; but since they've condemned abortion under any circumstances, it behooves them to make the church a welcoming environment for the single, pregnant woman.

Perhaps this explains the Republican Party's rather mind-boggling reaction to vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin's announcement that her 17-year-old daughter was five months pregnant. Rather than criticizing Bristol for making bad decisions (as they have so often told inner city welfare recipients), they praised her for her decision to keep the baby and marry the father. I'm not saying that the religiously and the politically conservative always agree on things, but Republicans have been marketing themselves as an ally of the Christian church for years. Where is their Christian charity?

(Sorry. I was trying to come up with an example that didn't involve politics, but this one seemed the most applicable. For the record, I consider myself an Independent, and have issues with the inconsistencies within the Democratic Party as well. They just aren't relevant to this blog. And reproductive rights are something I feel very strongly about.)

There's also still a double standard for men and women when it comes to sex partners--no doubt about it. I consider myself relatively open-minded and, overall, I think the sexual liberation of women is a good thing. Still, I often find myself secretly judging the sexually hyperactive college girl, and while I'm not a big fan of the campus Don Juans, I seem to see the world's Cleopatras in a far less favorable light. I'm definitely not immune to the kind of hypocrisy I'm accusing society of, and I'm not sure that admitting it makes it any better.

Wednesday, September 10, 2008

Broom Burning

I have to admit, it's awfully hard to take a movement seriously when its members are willing to put on a mask, grabbing a wand, and marching around the Federal Reserve Treasury Bank with a papier-mache pig's head just to get publicity for their cause. Frankly, I don't think anyone who sincerely wants to change women's place in society wants the type of attention that sort of shenanigans attracts. Feminists have spent centuries trying to convince the general public that women are not frivolous, melodramatic basket cases but serious, rational, contributing members of society. It's hard to see how the feminist witch movement furthers these claims.

Rountree's article touched on the feminist witches' reaction to the Salem Witch Trials only briefly: she mentioned some coven members disputed the "innocence" of the women hanged for witchcraft because they felt it reinforced women's roles as victims in a patriarchal society. I'm dying to know, what do such women make of the girls who made all the accusations? Some historical interpretations might lead one to believe that Ann Putnam Jr. and her friends made a pretty effective bid to reclaim "agency" all their own. Would their analysis make Putnam and the accusers helpless tools in the hands of an all-powerful patriarchy? Or did the extent of men's power in Puritan society force them to go after their own kind? If Puritan women were merely victims of patriarchy, how come a group of adolescent girls were able to bring entire congregations and courtrooms to their knees? History doesn't need to be rewritten for the trials to stand as a testament to women's ability to shake up the system.

And while I can see how invoking ancient symbolism with a modern twist could be a powerful rhetorical tool, I have to question its usefulness here. There's no question that our understanding of the present shades our interpretation of the past, and vice versa. Nevertheless, it seems like clinging to archaic symbols like the witch and the goddess only proves that they still hold power over us to this day. Once everyone has "goddess" on the brain, it's only a matter of time before someone reminds everyone that goddesses often turned out to be jealous, insecure bitches--just ask poor Arachne. And Christians weren't the only ones who blamed all the world's problems on women: who could forget Pandora's box? We shouldn't forget our past, but maybe it's time to move on.

In my opinion, the truly independent, modern woman has moved on from the "witch" and "goddess" archetypes altogether. Feminists should strive for the day when the "ordinary woman" is secure enough in her own identity that she doesn't need to make use of "witch" or "goddess" labels at all. If the "witch" and "goddess" roles are too extreme for women to actually emulate, why not abandon them completely? The well-balanced woman at the center of it all is true to herself and needs no external mythology for reassurance.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

See No Evil

"Evil" seems to be quite the buzzword these days! Every time you turn around, you're bombarded with the news that some opinionated individual or organization has labeled a person or practice they disagree with as being the e-word. In fact, when I Googled "evil" on CNN.com just a few minutes ago, the search engine came up with 3,207 entries on CNN's website alone. Romney, Huckabee, and Palin all used it at least once in their speeches at the Republican National Convention tonight, and it was likely thrown around a bit at the Democratic National Convention, too. I don't know how many people in American still believe in the kind of "Evil" Cotton Mather warns his readers about, but it's clear that the idea of evil is still with us.

Personally, I find it hard to believe in the kind of evil that requires a capital E. I'll be the first to admit, I'm very skeptical of the so-called supernatural world, and it would take a lot more than the book of a crusading minister to convince me of its existence. I find the world's everyday "evils"--the evil of child abuse, the evil of homelessness, etc.--much more compelling. On the other hand, it's hard to deny that the members of the human race are capable of committing extraordinarily cruel acts against their fellow man. I think the Salem Witch Trials themselves should be included in that category.

I seem to be presented with the idea of the supernatural world rather frequently, given my skepticism. It never ceases to amaze me how many grown and supposedly rational adults will proclaim the existence of ghosts, witchcraft, and the like as though it were gospel truth. Like most American children, my first exposure to the idea of witchcraft came in the form of fairytales and Disney movies--I remember the scene with Ursula the sea witch concocting a potion to turn Ariel into a human in The Little Mermaid particularly vividly. When I was in high school and middle school, my friend Vanessa (yes, THAT Vanessa, fellow Essay alumni) was a practicing Wiccan, although I don't know how seriously she took it. Every now and then I'd ask her if she ever saw any results from her "spells," which I considered to be more along the lines of informal experiments. Even though she claimed to have witnessed incredible occurences--lighting candles without lighter or matches and conversing with her dead grandfather--her voice never registered even a hint of awe or excitement. She might as well have been talking about the weather. As a result, I never took her stories about "magick" particularly seriously.

Believe it or not, I was actually on the receiving end of witchcraft accusations myself once. While I was attending a particularly conservative Christian school in the third grade, my "frenemy" Raven started a rumor that I was a witch. (Although with a name like "Raven," you'd think it would be the other way around.) Raven had a particularly vivid imagination, and usually her in-class speeches about being abducted by aliens went unchallenged by our teacher. However, because this was a school where the handbook banned students from wearing the peace symbol since it was supposedly a broken cross, the vice principal actually called me into his office to discuss the allegations. I don't really remember the details--our meeting couldn't have taken longer than five minutes. I believe he asked me if I knew about Raven's claims and whether there was any truth to them and I told him I had no idea what he or she was talking about. However, it seemed weird that the school's administration would actually get involved, and the incident played a big role in my parents' decision to move me to public school the next year.

Personally, I think we're in a lot more danger from narrow-mindedness and intolerance than we are from the work of any witch. Throughout history, people have displayed a tendency to label as "evil" the things they don't understand, and it doesn't look like we'll be changing our ways anytime soon. What would happen, I wonder, if we delayed judgment and considered the context when we encountered a practice or belief we didn't understand? And if we couldn't find common ground after that, couldn't we just agree to disagree? We're so quick to find the "evil" in other people that we rarely take the time to examine it in ourselves.