"The Panther Narrative" definitely reflects a change in print culture attitudes towards women. How much of a change is still a question open for debate.
We got the first clue that early American writers were moving away from sermon-y conversion narratives and more towards sensational adventure stories in the "confession" of Rachel Wall, whose public "confessions" consisted of barely-disguised boasts of her "nocturnal excursions."
In some ways, the Panther cave-woman's situation seems markedly improved over that of her predecessors'. However, a closer examination of the text reveals that her progress seems to be of a "two steps forward, one step back" nature. It's true, there's little direct criticism of the woman and her lover's decision to elope, but it's a mere four days after they leave society and its antiquated ideas about love and marriage behind that he comes to a band end and she finds herself in a sticky situation. Even the original version of the Panther narrative, where she planned and executes a clever escape from the Indians, wouldn't have been giving her too much credit. (Have you ever checked out early Americans' attitudes towards the Natives?) Yes, she kills her would-be rapist, but her assertion that she would prefer death to having her honor violated just goes to show that "uncleanness" was still a big deal. Moreover, the fact that she inherited this cave and some of its contents from the man she killed (in his sleep, not in a proper fight) detracts from the ingenuity that would have been required for her to survive in the wilderness for nine years.
Besides, in the beginning of this tall tale the narrator mentions the various foodstuffs found growing in the Western forests "afforded us very comfortable living." The real purpose of the Panther narrative? It's basically an advertising gimmick. "Living off the land out west: So easy, a cave-woman could do it."
Don't get me wrong--it was nice to read a story where the woman doesn't die at the end. But I find it highly suspicious that our first encounter with a woman who goes unpunished for her disobedience is in an obviously fictitious tale. That's not to say that fiction can't be a good indicator of cultural realities, but I suspect early American women would have preferred a bit more progress in the real world.
Wednesday, September 24, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I found your blog very interesting. It's funny because so many of the rest of us are so excited about the fact that a woman finally doesn't die, and you noted something different. You make a very good point, though. It is really suspicious that this narrative is so fictitious. I honestly think that a woman wrote it because I don't think a man would go into such outrageous detail to tell a story about a woman's strength. I don't know though - interesting things to think about. Good blog, I enjoyed it!
Post a Comment