Wednesday, September 10, 2008

Broom Burning

I have to admit, it's awfully hard to take a movement seriously when its members are willing to put on a mask, grabbing a wand, and marching around the Federal Reserve Treasury Bank with a papier-mache pig's head just to get publicity for their cause. Frankly, I don't think anyone who sincerely wants to change women's place in society wants the type of attention that sort of shenanigans attracts. Feminists have spent centuries trying to convince the general public that women are not frivolous, melodramatic basket cases but serious, rational, contributing members of society. It's hard to see how the feminist witch movement furthers these claims.

Rountree's article touched on the feminist witches' reaction to the Salem Witch Trials only briefly: she mentioned some coven members disputed the "innocence" of the women hanged for witchcraft because they felt it reinforced women's roles as victims in a patriarchal society. I'm dying to know, what do such women make of the girls who made all the accusations? Some historical interpretations might lead one to believe that Ann Putnam Jr. and her friends made a pretty effective bid to reclaim "agency" all their own. Would their analysis make Putnam and the accusers helpless tools in the hands of an all-powerful patriarchy? Or did the extent of men's power in Puritan society force them to go after their own kind? If Puritan women were merely victims of patriarchy, how come a group of adolescent girls were able to bring entire congregations and courtrooms to their knees? History doesn't need to be rewritten for the trials to stand as a testament to women's ability to shake up the system.

And while I can see how invoking ancient symbolism with a modern twist could be a powerful rhetorical tool, I have to question its usefulness here. There's no question that our understanding of the present shades our interpretation of the past, and vice versa. Nevertheless, it seems like clinging to archaic symbols like the witch and the goddess only proves that they still hold power over us to this day. Once everyone has "goddess" on the brain, it's only a matter of time before someone reminds everyone that goddesses often turned out to be jealous, insecure bitches--just ask poor Arachne. And Christians weren't the only ones who blamed all the world's problems on women: who could forget Pandora's box? We shouldn't forget our past, but maybe it's time to move on.

In my opinion, the truly independent, modern woman has moved on from the "witch" and "goddess" archetypes altogether. Feminists should strive for the day when the "ordinary woman" is secure enough in her own identity that she doesn't need to make use of "witch" or "goddess" labels at all. If the "witch" and "goddess" roles are too extreme for women to actually emulate, why not abandon them completely? The well-balanced woman at the center of it all is true to herself and needs no external mythology for reassurance.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

He Chelsea,
I think you`re absolutely right. Nowadays, there is no reason for a woman to dress like a witch in order to convice other people of her beliefs.
I guess, this is the wrong way to atract attention! Women acting like witches even ridcule their own ideals because no one takes them seriously any more.

Sarah Livingston said...

Wow! I never thought about your point about the Salem Witch Trials and how though they were committing these horrible crimes, those girls were really just taking control of their own lives. Well, I mean we talked about it in class, so I guess I never thought about the fact that the younger generation of women were stealing what little agency the accused women had and gaining more agency for themselves in turn. They even got to have power of the fates of a few men, which never would have happened. It seems like the “witches” described in the article are pretty radical, so I would imagine that they would blame the Puritan patriarchic system for the young girls’ actions. That was also a very good point about Pandora and the other Greek myths, I had forgotten all the wrath of a “goddess scorned.” Great post—lots of interesting ideas!

stephanie m said...

Chelsea,

I agree with what you are saying. Especially about how feminists have been trying to convince public that they are not crazy,but by with this feminist witch movement, it is probably doing the opposite.

I also like what you had to say about how women today should strive to move past this need of having to label themselves "witches" or "goddesses" and be secure enough in who they are now.

Amanda Irvin said...

Hi Chelsea,
Excellent post! I was thinking about some of the same issues as I was reading and especially like your idea that truly progressive women have moved past the witch/goddess ideals altogether. Feminist, historical reclamation can be useful, but I too am not sure it should dictate life in progressive, contemporary society. Great thoughts!
AI