Wednesday, October 1, 2008

The Not-So Happy Medium

In a weird way, it was rather refreshing to see society's "rules" for young women set out in black and white. Seeing societal norms in print only reinforces how self-contradictory and unattainable they really are.

For starters, women in early America were supposed to be confident in the world of romance while remaining sexually in the dark. How can a woman project confidence when dealing with subjects she knows nothing about? Is it any wonder that women ended up getting pregnant out of wedlock? This is taking abstinence-only education to a whole new level. Alphonzo's assertion that women must remain intellectually and emotionally childlike in order to attract a mate is downright creepy.

The idea that women should respond politely to ladies' men but refrain from engaging in any coquetry of their own is equally preposterous. We all knew there was a "double standard," but seeing it written out like that definitely makes one question just how Alphonzo and his brethren reached the conclusion that they were women's intellectual superiors.

Alphonzo's criticism of "prudes" is perhaps the most ridiculous of all. A woman who behaves too modestly is even more likely to be considered sexually suspect than a total floozy, he says. One can't help but wonder if this is just his way of consoling himself when women reject his advances.

Finally, only a few moments after we are told that most women don't like to read, the address's author criticizes women for their terrible taste in literature. Women are told that by choosing books that will increase their feminine charm, they can get away with reading less. Why worry about the quality of reading material that women are exposed to if they don't read any of it anyway? Doesn't that inadvertently suggest that no woman will read his letter unless it's a load of crap to begin with?


Women shouldn't try to live out a particular role but be true to themselves, Alphonzo says. But doesn't that mean they should also reject the role he's just set out for them? Women are supposed to be deferential: they have no control over their lives, yet society still holds them responsible for every little imaginary fault they can come up with.

I'd like to say that things have changed today, but there do seem to be definite parallels between the garbage espoused by magazines from the 18th century and that advocated by the magazines of today. Women are still encouraged to find that impossible middle ground, and it's a razor-sharp line that no man or woman can actually walk.

1 comment:

Doe said...

I so enjoyed reading your post. I think you phrased the issues really well. I especially agreed with your observation that the quality of reading material would be a mute point since it would mean they would not be reading his article! How astute!

I also think that much of the material produced today in magazines, etc. provide an arena of impossibility for women much as these texts did in early America. The conflicting dictates of the print media we read in class parallels the super-model, super woman icon of our pop culture media. She does not exist because of the irrational double standard.