The first show that comes to mind as the modern equivalent of early American romance novels is the guilty pleasure "Desperate Housewives." Sex out of wedlock, extramarital affairs, and disobedient daughters, oh my! Gabrielle would be castigated up one side and down the other for her penchant for sleeping with minors, her unbridled vanity, and her scanty attire. Susan would be similarly censured for being a divorcee. Lynette would be in trouble for wearing the pants in the family and God only knows what she'd say about Edie. The author would likely have the most sympathy for Bree, with her struggle to maintain traditional values in the face of a morally "progressive" community.
"Grey's Anatomy" would be another target for his or her darts of displeasure. Meredith's promiscuity, Izzie's child out of wedlock, and Christina's planned abortion all fly in the face of conservative values. And I haven't actually seen "Gossip Girl," but I've heard enough to know that its depiction of teenaged privilege and the so-called "hook-up culture" would upset most older Americans. Crime dramas, soap operas, to say nothing of cable shows--there's enough sleeping around on television to make the author's head spin!
However, I think a modern day cultural critic, like the angry letter-writers of yore, would be overestimating the impact entertainment media have in our lives. TV networks wouldn't show these programs if the ratings weren't thriving. Everyone loves a good scandal. Besides, how would cultural critics know what was on these shows if they weren't watching?
1 comment:
Hi Chelsea,
I'm glad you chose to bring up contemporary television as an example of a source of depravity. The problems that supposably result from indulging in novels can certainly be applied here. I thought about using this example as well, but I didn't feel that I commanded much ethos on the subject, seeing as I rarely watch T.V. (though I don't think one needs to to know what's out there). Anyway, good post.
Post a Comment