Thursday, October 16, 2008

Down with Love

I think the texts we discussed in class the other day made it clear that the idea of marriage based on love was one old-school Americans loved to hate. It's obvious why parents would see the demise of arranged marriage as a threat to their authority--how could any family eke out a good business or political deal without the ability to use its daughters as bargaining chips? Clearly, the best way to maintain control over your daughter was to convince her that you were the only person with her best interests at heart. While seduction tales were obviously meant to be dramatic and entertaining, the authors' main goal seems to be to convince young women that members of the opposite sex cannot be trusted.

In many ways, the seduction narratives echo the confession narratives we read earlier in the semester. In "Story of Amelia," Amelia mourns the "youthful folly" that led her astray. Like the confessing criminals of old, Amelia states that her main goal in writing her letter is to warn other girls not to make the same mistakes she did--"let them learn of me."

If seduction narratives are the new confession narratives, it stands to reason that love is the new sin. Young women are reputed to be especially at risk for romance, just as they were once seen as being more susceptible to sin. This time it is love, not sin, that is the "enemy within [Amelia's] own bosom. It is love, not sin, that makes her heart "weak and susceptible."

The other stories also seem to be geared towards warning young ladies of the dangers of love. These authors are definitely out to instruct girls in what they ought and ought not to do. They have only their best interests at heart. And if they make some money from selling these scandalous stories, that's just an added bonus.

2 comments:

Julie S. said...

I always enjoy reading your posts. It interested me that you compared the seduction and confession narratives. I also picked up on the similar instructive phrases--which are (as always) carefully tucked into the narrative by male authors imitating the female voice. I hadn't thought about love as the new sin, but I see your point. I certainly agree that the seduction narratives carry on the tradition of emphasizing female vulnerability and weakness.

mrmurphey said...

I loved, loved, loved your post. You made some excellent points. My favorite was that in the seduction narrative, "love was the new sin." In previous texts it was witchery or murder that brought a woman down-but now it is love! It makes sense that parents who stood to financially profit by their daughter's marriage would be incensed at the idea of marrying for love.